Spice Up Your Life: Must-Have Seasonings and Condiments for Every Kitchen Pantry

Credit: Primal Kitchen

Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the web’s best products. If you purchase through our links, we may receive a commission. Our editorial team is independent and only endorses products we believe in.

Whether it’s a simple steak or a fancy spread, spices are one of the most crucial things to have in your kitchen arsenal. They’re an easy way to turn basic ingredients into cultural masterpieces.

But, what is a spice? Just salt and pepper? Fancy taco seasonings? These are the important philosophical issues of our time.

Although the category is overwhelming, the good news is that just a few key spices and condiments can elevate your whole cooking repertoire. And although they can be expensive, with proper storage in a cool, dark place they can last a while and each serving typically ends up being just a few pennies.

From condiments for chicken to spicy cajun seasoning, these are the best spices for your pantry.

We like

We don't like

Shopping Guide For Spices

Shopping for spices can seem like its own adventure—it’s both exciting and daunting. Knowing what brands to trust, what buzzwords actually matter, and where to find them will help you spend your money wisely. Here are a few tips:

Look for Sourcing Information & Trusted Brands

Try to find sellers that can provide extensive information on where they source their spices and how fresh they are. A well-known brand probably has a better track record than a new Amazon seller that can’t provide trustworthy details on how they find their products.

Start with Kits

Some shops offer complete spice kits. This could be a great way to get started building out your collection as they likely have everything you absolutely need as a beginner. Down the line you can add more niche varieties.

Don’t Overbuy

We’ve probably all seen almost-full canisters of spices that we had to buy for just one recipe. Keep in mind that it’s probably better to start with smaller sizes until you know that you frequently use a certain spice. No need to waste money or shelf space on something that you rarely incorporate into recipes.

Our Top Picks

Here are some of our favorite selections.

Best for Burgers

Amazon

Weber Flavor Bomb Burger Seasoning

$4
$4
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

Go with a classic. Weber’s Flavor Bomb Burger seasoning is the overall pick on Amazon for a reason. It’s made with ingredients like salt, brown sugar, garlic powder, and more to give a complex flavor to any patty.

We like

We don't like

Best for Chicken

OSMO

Roasted Garlic Sea Salt

$16.99
$16.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: OSMO

Osmo’s bestselling Roasted Garlic Sea Salt is only made with salt and roasted garlic, but still offers a sweet-and-savory combination for brines or rubs. Although not made for chicken alone, there’s just something great about a hint of garlic with a tender chicken breast.

We like

We don't like

Best for Salmon

Just Spices

Salmon Allrounder

$6.99
$6.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Just Spices

Just Spices’ quality ingredients come together to level up all fish dishes. Fennel, mustard, paprika, and red onion come together to make any cut of salmon pop. It works as a marinade or dry rub.

We like

We don't like

Best for Steaks

Amazon

Kinder's Organic Buttery Steakhouse Rub

$7.40
$7.40
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

Is there anything better than a juicy piece of red meat cooked in real butter? Kinder’s organic Buttery Steakhouse seasoning lets you make restaurant-quality steaks at your own grill. It’s also non-GMO and free of MSGs.

We like

We don't like

Best for Turkey

Amazon

McCormick Culinary Poultry Seasoning

$11.97
$11.97
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

McCormick’s Poultry Seasoning is made of a simple blend of thyme, sage, marjoram, rosemary, black pepper, and nutmeg that’ll make turkey taste like Thanksgiving at any time of year.

We like

We don't like

Best for Pork Chops

Amazon

Dan-O's Seasoning Medium 2 Bottle Combo

$24.99
$24.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

The Dan-O’s two-pack combination of original and spicy seasonings is a versatile blend that can be used with any cooking technique—and satisfies mild palettes and heat cravers alike. Customers love using them for pork chops, though they’re good for multiple dishes.

We like

We don't like

Best Oil to Season Cast Iron

Field Company

Cast Iron Seasoning Oil

$44
$44
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Field Company

Field Company’s time-tested seasoning oil uses a mixture of organic grapeseed oil, organic sunflower oil, and beeswax to keep your pans nonstick without dangerous forever chemicals. There’s a reason it has a couple hundred five-star reviews.

We like

We don't like

Best Taco Seasonings

Siete

Mild Taco Seasoning

$20
$20
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Siete

This mild seasoning formula has been revamped to balance the right amount of spice while still letting the bold flavors of tomato, garlic, chili, and cumin come out for an authentic Taco Night. Get an extra pack or two to sprinkle it on french fries or other side dishes.

We like

We don't like

Best Cajun Seasoning

Amazon

Louisiana Favorites No MSG Cajun Creole Seasoning Bundle

$12.89
$12.89
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

The first time I visited New Orleans, I came back with a few cans of the famous Tony C’s—and used it for just about everything. Although technically a “creole” seasoning (less spicy), it still evokes the Louisiana flair. Add the famous “Slap Ya Mama” cajun blend for the complete rotation.

We like

We don't like

Best Hot Dog Condiments

Amazon

Heinz Tomato Ketchup

$2.44
$2.44
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

What else do you need for a ballpark dog? Heinz is iconic for a reason. It’s maybe not the healthiest condiment of all time, but I’m simply not willing to trade the sweet flavor to save a few calories.

We like

We don't like

Amazon

French's Classic Yellow Mustard

$2.39
$2.39
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

Add in a line of French’s tangy yellow mustard and you’re good to go.

We like

We don't like

Amazon

Heinz Dill Relish

$6.53
$6.53
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

There’s never anything wrong with a few gobs of dill relish to take your hot dog to the next level.

We like

We don't like

Best Sandwich Condiments

Primal Kitchen

Avocado Lime Dipping Sauce

$9.99
$9.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Primal Kitchen

Better-for-you sauce brand Primal Kitchen recently launched their spins on drive-thru favorite dipping sauces. I’ve tried them all and particularly like the Avocado Lime and Yum Yum sauce. Best of all? No seed oils.

We like

We don't like

Best Low Calorie Condiments

Amazon

Cholula Original Hot Sauce

$4.29
$4.29
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

Hot sauce is great because it literally has zero calories. Cholula strikes a good balance between spice and taste.

We like

We don't like

Amazon

Huy Fong Sriracha Hot Chili Sauce

$12.99
$12.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

It’s not 2020 anymore—sriracha is back on the menu! Each tablespoon only has six calories and goes great with a lot of food groups.

We like

We don't like

Amazon

Bachan's Japanese Barbecue Sauce 2 Pack

$23.98
$23.98
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

Bachan’s Japanese barbecue sauce has quickly taken over grocery stores across the country. It comes in a wide variety of flavors and is made with simple, non-GMO ingredients.

We like

We don't like

Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
OSMO
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Just Spices
Coupon:
Coupon:
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Field Company
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Siete
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Amazon
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Amazon
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Primal Kitchen
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Amazon
Coupon:
Coupon:
Best for Burgers
Best for Chicken
OSMO
$16.99
$16.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Best for Salmon
Just Spices
$6.99
$6.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Best for Steaks
Best for Turkey
Best for Pork Chops
Best Oil to Season Cast Iron
Field Company
$44
$44
Code:
Copy Icon
Best Taco Seasonings
Best Cajun Seasoning
Best Hot Dog Condiments
Amazon
$2.44
$2.44
Code:
Copy Icon
Amazon
$6.53
$6.53
Code:
Copy Icon
Best Sandwich Condiments
Primal Kitchen
$9.99
$9.99
Code:
Copy Icon
Best Low Calorie Condiments

Organizing Your Spice Pantry

A well-organized spice rack could be the difference between a massive headache and a pleasant cooking experience. Keeping track of everything also allows you to maintain peak freshness.

Consider the following tips to optimize your spice cabinet:

  • Label each spice clearly and distinctly. Most spices have small variations so getting the details right is key. (Is this recipe calling for garlic powder or garlic salt?)
  • Store spices in airtight containers in a cool, dark place.
  • Regularly check your spices’ freshness and restock if they start to lose their punch.

Let's explore how to shop for spices to make the process seamless and exciting:

Evermill

Custom Counter Top Rack

$269
$269
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Evermill

Evermill lets you build your own custom spice rack with 18 different spices—just about everything you could need in an elegant display. You might get overwhelmed by the number of options you can pick from. But this is a sure-fire way to keep your spices organized and fresh.

We like

We don't like

Hexclad

HexMill Salt and Pepper Grinder Set

$258
$258
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Hexclad

It’s a fact that fresh-cracked black pepper is better than pre-ground pepper. HexClad’s Pepper Grinder is a beast of a kitchen tool. It has ten grind settings and comes with a lifetime warranty. I use this just about every day and love the conversation it strikes up when sitting on the counter.

We like

We don't like

Year & Day

Salt Cellar

$55
$55
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Year & Day

Year & Day’s elegant salt holder comes in four colors and a wide-mouth opening for easy access. Use it in the kitchen or at the table for quick pinches to liven up any dish.

We like

We don't like

Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Evermill
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Year & Day
Evermill
$269
$269
Code:
Copy Icon
Year & Day
$55
$55
Code:
Copy Icon
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.

Elevate Your Cooking with Our Curated Spice Collection

Above every recommendation in spices is one rule: Use them!

Building a comprehensive spice collection is a fun journey that turns your regular middle-of-the-week dinner into an exciting getaway to a new place. By focusing on the vital choices and mastering the techniques, you can instantly upgrade your cooking game.

Spices don’t go bad easily, but they do lose flavor over time. So have fun, put your scientist hat on and try new concoctions!

Shop our suggested range of spices, food, and more for daily inspiration and pieces you don’t want to miss.

Shop The Edit

Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
OSMO
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Just Spices
Coupon:
Coupon:
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Field Company
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Siete
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Primal Kitchen
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Amazon
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Amazon
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Amazon
Coupon:
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Evermill
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Year & Day

Additional Reading

No items found.