Unveiling the Best Eye Makeup Remover Options: Gentle Solutions for Effortless Cleansing

Credit: @truebotanicals

Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the web’s best products. If you purchase through our links, we may receive a commission. Our editorial team is independent and only endorses products we believe in.

We like

We don't like

If there is one thing you can do to keep your skin in peak condition, it’s thoroughly clean your face every night—especially the eye area. We all know that feeling of being too tired and lazy at the end of the day and wanting to dive straight into bed. But getting into the habit of washing away any of the day’s makeup and impurities will have you waking up looking fresher and help to prevent your pores from clogging. 

What to Consider When Choosing an Eye Makeup Remover

The skin around the eye area is the most delicate on the face, so finding an eye makeup remover that works for your skin is the beginning of a life-long relationship. You need a cleanser that is strong enough to remove products like mascara and black eyeliner, while also being gentle enough not to irritate the eyes. 

Your Skin Type

Before you invest in an eye makeup remover the first thing to take into account is your skin type. Those with oily complexions or prone to breakouts should opt for an oil-free and noncomedogenic option to avoid overloading the skin. Anyone with dry skin should go for a bi-phase eye makeup remover as it will provide a deep clean without stripping the skin of moisture. 

Remover Type

Eye makeup remover comes in a variety of formats. Cleansing balms have been trending recently due to how gentle they are at taking off eye makeup, while traditional creams and milks remain skincare staples. Remover pads are a great choice for those looking for a hassle-free and easy nighty routine. 

Ingredients

If your eyes are easily irritated, definitely choose a fragrance-free eye makeup remover. Colloidal oatmeal is a great ingredient for soothing redness—so keep an eye out for cleansers containing it as it will help to calm your skin. Hyaluronic acid infused removers can also aid in reducing the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. 

Our Top Picks

Best For Sensitive Eyes

Sephora

The INKEY List Oat Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm

$13
$13
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Sephora

Suitable for all skin types, this gentle cleansing balm breaks down everything from waterproof mascara, makeup, SPF and dirt to leave your skin with a clean and fresh glow. It also contains our favorite natural skincare ingredient colloidal oatmeal to calm and soothe the skin, as well as oat kernel oil for an added dose of moisture and hydration. 

We like

We don't like

Best For Sensitive Skin

Amazon

La Roche-Posay Respectissime Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover

$20
$20
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

My personal favorite skincare brand and recommended by dermatologists everywhere, if you have a delicate complexion you are in safe hands with any of the La Roche-Posay products. Their water-proof eye makeup remover was designed especially for those with sensitive skin and the fragrance-free formula is also safe to use for contact lens wearers. 

We like

We don't like

Best For Waterproof Eye Makeup

Amazon

Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover

$10
$10
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

We love how waterproof mascara holds up throughout the day, but not the battle of trying to remove it at night. Luckily Cetaphil have created this makeup remover to take off even the most stubborn products. Both dermatologist and Ophthalmologist tested, this remover is both oil and fragrance free and infused with soothing plant extracts such as aloe vera, ginseng and green tea.

We like

We don't like

Pond's Cold Cream Cleanser

Amazon

Pond's Cold Cream Cleanser

$7
$7
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

This bathroom shelf staple has achieved almost legendary skin care status. It provides the face with a deep clean removing even the blackest mascara while also delivering moisture—to leave your base looking fresh and soft. The drugstore price tag also makes it one of the best value eye makeup removers on the market.

We like

We don't like

Best Budget Buy

Amazon

e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration Off Makeup Remover

$7
$7
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

E.l.f are the go-to brand for high-quality products at drugstore prices and this all-in-one makeup remover is one of their best offerings yet. The bi-phase formula melts away eye makeup, even waterproof mascara without leaving any grease or residue on the skin. The best part is that it has also been infused with hyaluronic acid, squalane, and niacinamide to soften and condition your lashes.

We like

We don't like

Best Splurge

Sephora

Lancôme Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover

$39
$39
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Sephora

If you take your skincare game seriously and are looking to invest in a luxury eye makeup remover, this Bi-Facil option from Lancôme feels like a dream on the skin. The combination of both oil and water makes taking off your makeup seamless as the products just melt away easily. We also love how it comes in 3 size options—mini, standard and value.

We like

We don't like

Best Soothing Eye Makeup Remover

Amazon

CeraVe Eye Makeup Remover

$8.50
$8.50
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

The combo of ceramides in this eye makeup remover help to maintain the skin’s protective barrier while still managing to wash away any products and dirt. The formula is free from alcohol and fragrance making it sensitive skin friendly and the added bonus of hyaluronic acid helps to keep the skin's natural moisture intact.

We like

We don't like

Best Hydrating Eye Makeup Remover

Sephora

EADEM Dew Dream- Hydrating Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm with Tiger Grass

$30
$30
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Sephora

This jelly-to-oil-to-milk eye makeup remover is packed to the brim of skin-loving ingredients. Allantoin hydrates and supports cell turnover, while tiger grass heals damaged skin. It also contains kalahari melon and moringa extracts to soak up excess sebum and keep your pores clear.

We like

We don't like

Best Balm

True Botanicals

Ginger Turmeric Cleansing Balm

$48
$48
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: True Botanicals

I personally absolutely adore this cleansing balm and have repurchased it constantly. Not only does it remove all your makeup gently, it leaves your skin brighter and more radiant. The turmeric and ginger definitely help to lift my complexion when it's looking dull—especially in the Winter months.

We like

We don't like

Best Pads

Amazon

Almay Biodegradable Makeup Remover Pads

$8
$8
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

First thing to note about these Almay makeup remover pads is that they are biodegradable, which isn’t always the case. A lazy-girl beauty hack—If you have a habit of sleeping in your makeup, invest in a tub of these to take the hard work out of removing your makeup. In fact everyone could do with having some in their bathroom to ensure you always go to bed with a clean face no matter how tired you are.

We like

We don't like

Best Cleansing Water

Amazon

Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water

$13
$13
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

Bioderma are the original inventor of micellar water and their face and eye cleanser is seen as a skincare essential by many. The no-rinse formula can be used both morning and night to ensure your skin is always kept cleansed and free from dirt and bacteria. Formulated at skin PH, it won’t disrupt your natural levels but instead help to soothe and calm the surface.

We like

We don't like

Best Oil Based Makeup Remover

Amazon

Mario Badescu Carnation Eye Makeup Remover Oil

$6
$6
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Amazon

Despite being an oil, this eye makeup remover feels surprisingly lightweight and works effectively to melt away mascara, eyeliner and eyeshadows. It effortlessly dissolves products without having to rub the eyes, leaving the skin looking soft and supple as opposed to red and irritated.

We like

We don't like

Best Bi-Phase

Sephora

Glossier Milky Oil Dual-Phase Waterproof Makeup Remover

$16
$16
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Sephora

Micellar water and weightless oil work together here to remove makeup gently while also infusing the skin with comfrey root extract to calm dry and irritated skin. Suitable for all skin types— this is a great everyday cleanser as it also contains vitamin B5 for extra moisture.

We like

We don't like

Best Clean Beauty Pick

Sephora

Farmacy Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm

$36
$36
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Sephora

Loaded full of naturally skin-nourishing ingredients, this cleanser from Farmacy effortlessly takes away waterproof mascara, makeup, SPF and impurities while also working to improve the overall texture of your skin. Sunflower and ginger root oils act as the cleanser, while turmeric and moringa extract remove dirt as papaya enzymes exfoliate your pores— to give you cleaner and smoother looking skin. 

We like

We don't like

Best For Sensitive Eyes
Best For Waterproof Eye Makeup
Pond's Cold Cream Cleanser
Best Soothing Eye Makeup Remover
Best Balm
True Botanicals
$48
$48
Code:
Copy Icon
Best Cleansing Water
Best Oil Based Makeup Remover
Best Clean Beauty Pick

Eye Makeup Remover FAQs

Now you’ve seen the top picks available, keep reading to find out how to best use your eye makeup remover and what to look out for if you have particularly sensitive skin. 

What’s the most gentle way to clean eye makeup?

If you are using a balm or a milk, gently massage the product in to melt your makeup off the skin. Then with a cotton pad or face cloth wipe away your makeup. Rinse with lukewarm water and repeat if necessary.  If you are using a micellar water, apply the water to a cotton pad and hold over the eye for a few seconds, then wipe. 

What type of eye makeup remover should I use If I have sensitive skin?

Stay away from any product with fragrance, alcohol or parabens. Non-comedogenic formulas will also help you to avoid redness and breakouts. 

Can you use eye makeup remover on the face?

Some cleansers work as both face and eye makeup removers. If you prefer to streamline your makeup routine go for a balm or milk cleanser, to clean everything in one go. On days when you are wearing heavier eye-makeup or waterproof mascara go-for a designated eye makeup remover.

Looking for more cleansing advice? Take a look at our guide on washing your face correctly. Make sure to read more in our beauty edit for more product reviews and recommendations. And browse our beauty shop to browse all our favorite picks!

No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.

Shop The Edit

Additional Reading

No items found.