In partnership with Good Chop. Editor’s Note: We only select and work with partners that meet our quality standards, so you can rest assured we only endorse products we believe in.
Is there an entree more satisfying or delicious than a juicy cut of meat? When responsibly raised and cooked simply, a ribeye, sirloin, or filet mignon truly cannot be beat.
The only problem is that finding local, quality meat is trickier than it seems. As I’ve begun investing more effort into eating clean protein, I’ve come to realize that the meat industry isn’t as transparent as I’d like it to be – and making an extra trip to a local butcher isn’t a to-do I particularly enjoy (it’s expensive, too).
So, I opted to try out a meat delivery service, and then figured why not try two? I did the heavy lifting (though it was admittedly only from my front door to the kitchen) for you – and ultimately found one winning option for easy, affordable, and – most importantly – high quality meat I can trust. Welcome to the meat delivery service throwdown, featuring Good Chop and Butcher Box! Below, I break down how Good Chop and ButcherBox compare on price, sourcing, customization, and convenience so you can decide which subscription is actually worth it.
We like
We don't like
Featured Product
Best Value: Which Is Less Expensive Per Portion?
When comparing meat subscriptions, price per portion matters more than box price alone. Good Chop and ButcherBox both offer a great value proposition: High-quality meat and seafood delivered directly to your door at an affordable price? Sign me up.
Good Chop: Good Chop’s Medium Box is $149 and includes up to 36 portions or 14 lbs of your choice. The Large Box (up to 72 portions or 28 lbs) is $269, and the Extra Large Box (up to 108 portions or 42 lbs) is $359, meaning the price per portion starts at $3.32. Plus, if you use code TQE130E, you can enjoy $130 off across your first four boxes!
Butcher Box: ButcherBox’s $169 Custom ‘Classic Box’ includes 9-14 lbs of meat. The Custom ‘Big Box’ is $306 and includes only 18-26 lbs. At these prices, you could be paying over 10% more for the same amount of meat.
Bottom Line: Good Chop offers more meat for less money, especially for households that cook protein regularly.
Winner: Good Chop
We like
We don't like
We like
We don't like
We like
We don't like
Save $130 across your first four boxes with code ‘TQE130E’
Best Sourcing: Where Does The Meat Come From?
Sourcing matters. Not just for taste, but for transparency, sustainability, and supporting local farms.
Good Chop exclusively sources its meat and seafood from the U.S. They work with independent family farms and fisheries, supporting local economies and offering premium quality.
ButcherBox, on the other hand, imports most of its beef from Australia.
I really love how Good Chop supports local ranchers and businesses across the country. They take the crown in this area.
Winner: Good Chop
Best Customization: Who Lets You Choose Your Cuts?
Good Chop is fully customizable. They have over 80 different cuts of beef, pork, chicken, and seafood, and you get to pick what you want. Plus, they offer sides and desserts to complete your meal. Also, if you’ll be away for a month or just want to pause, Good Chop lets you easily change your delivery date or cancel at anytime. They also offer a 100% satisfaction money-back guarantee.
ButcherBox has a lower-cost option for $146, but you only get to choose which type of meat you want, and they decide which cuts you get. Their customizable option costs $169.
Winner: Good Chop
Convenience: Who Made My Life Easier?
Good Chop: Simply put, Good Chop makes things as simple as possible. Each box is delivered to your door on your schedule, and you can cancel anytime. Plus, you can expect everything to be vacuum-sealed and frozen at peak freshness so you can stock your freezer and cook it whenever you’re ready.
Butcher Box: Similar story here. The brand offers a lot of flexibility in terms of delivery and cancellation, and everything is packed like a pro!
Winner: Tie
Good Chop vs. ButcherBox: Who Each Is Best For
Good Chop is best if you:
- Want full control over every cut in your box
- Prefer 100% U.S.-sourced meat and seafood
- Want the lowest price per portion
- Like stocking your freezer with variety
ButcherBox is best if you:
- Prefer curated boxes with minimal decision-making
- Don’t mind imported beef
- Want a simpler, preset subscription
Good Chop vs. ButcherBox FAQs
Is Good Chop cheaper than ButcherBox?
Yes. On average, Good Chop offers a lower cost per portion and more meat per box.
Is ButcherBox meat grass-fed?
Some ButcherBox beef is grass-fed, but much of it is sourced internationally.
Can you customize every Good Chop box?
Yes. Every Good Chop subscription allows full customization.
Final Verdict: Good Chop Wins For 2026
While both Good Chop and ButcherBox have great products and a quality offering, based on a few different categories I looked at, Good Chop is the clear favorite.
Good Chop is the more affordable of the two subscriptions, and if you use ‘TQE120E’ you can even get $120 off across your first four boxes.
Good Chop sources exclusively from American farms and fisheries that are committed to quality and sustainability. I love how they support local businesses and invest in the local economy.
Finally, Good Chop lets you customize your box so much more than ButcherBox. You get to pick from over 80 different cuts of beef, chicken, pork, and seafood. It’s a no-brainer.
Overall Winner: Good Chop. If you’re looking for high-quality American meat and seafood that you can pick, with easy delivery options and at an affordable price, then go with Good Chop.
Overall Winner: Good Chop
Use code ‘TQE130E’ for $130 off Good Chop
